Friday, August 19, 2011

Breaking Silence


I recently experienced an internal code of silence that surprised me greatly. It’s been over 40 years since I was raped by my uncle, and yet I found it difficult to talk about. It seemed as if I would be punished in some unknown way for speaking up. Over 40 years of an ominous, ethereal lock on my tongue.

After I’d dealt with the crushing aftermath of resurfacing memories; after I’d been kicked in the chest and got back up again; after I’d spent time in therapy (finding a good therapist is a long, sometimes scary story), I tried to report him. I found his county. I called the police. They would not even go and take a look. I knew he still had access to young children, but they wanted the name of a child who was currently complaining of the abuse. What had happened to me didn’t matter.

It had been years of molestation (such a schmaltzy word for another form of rape), followed by a single night of a violent act involving a large, heavily muscled, very angry man and an eight year old child often called Half-Pint for her tiny size. I know something went on for about two more years, but I have no memories of what that was. Yet.

This code of silence, this inability to open my mouth and speak the truth astonishes me. And yet, I hear people wonder why rape and incest is under-reported. I hear them marvel that a character in a book who has just been raped doesn’t rise up and slay her attacker. I hear them blame the victim for not being enough, for not being strong enough to fight back, to raise the stakes from rape to murder. I hear them talk from a position of strength and a lack of personal knowledge. I hear in them some of the reasons why the silence continues.

But what can be done to rescue the children living in their own private hell and unlock their voices?


One of the manuscripts I’m working on contains incest. Some of it is based on my experiences and some is fiction. There are many reasons why I’m having trouble working on this one. Part of it is the silence. Part of it is public reaction to such subjects in books. Part of it is this business of writing.

The details can be graphic, the subject matter taboo. Does that make it not suitable for young children? Does that mean the only readers of such a book should be adults? Are children younger than 12 only allowed to be raped and not to read about it? If I make the character older, would it be suitable for Tweens? Teenagers?

Am I falling into the trap that says this doesn’t happen to little children? If we admit this does happen to young children, are we failing as a society?

I don’t have the answer for my manuscript let alone for our society or those many thousands of children who feel hope has abandoned them or that this life they lead is normal and there is nothing else, no other way to live.

Do you?


In case you’re wondering, my uncle’s dead now. Found that out through an accident of the internet on a genealogical site.

11 comments:

Laurel said...

Write it. Write it true. The worst thing that can happen is the market won't accept it. So what? It should still be written. It will be good for you and it is WRITTEN. Someone else who might need to read it never will if it has never been committed to word.

j a zobair said...

Exactly. What Laurel said. I think the only question for you is what a difference such a book would have meant for you when you were going through it. Not everyone has to have their child read it, at least not at a particularly young age. But the children who need to make some sense of what has happened--and to understand as fully as possible that they did nothing wrong, nothing to deserve what happened--should have access to that information. To your story.

I am so sorry for what you went through. Believe me, I know exactly how inadequate that statement is, but I hope somehow you can sense the full import of my sorrow through this stupid medium.

jjdebenedictis said...

Ditto the others: You have to write the book that needs to be written.

(((*hugs*))) for you as you get this painful truth out.

It's weird and unpleasant for me to admit this, but while I don't believe in the death penalty, there are certain crimes where I do feel a deep, vengeful wish that the aggressor could be made to not exist. I don't really want anyone or anything to act on that bloodthirsty impulse--yet I feel it.

And those who hurt/destroy others for their own pleasure/benefit tend to be the ones that trigger that impulse the most strongly. I'm glad he doesn't exist anymore.

fairyhedgehog said...

Oh no. That's horrific. I'm so sorry you went through that - I just can't find the words to tell you how I feel about it.

It sounds like it needs to be written. I wouldn't like to be writing it and I couldn't because I don't have the experience to understand how it was or how it can be.

Phoenix Sullivan said...

I know what courage it takes to come out about such things. What galls me is how callously others treated you in the forum where you took those first steps. To acknowledge how horrific it must have been but not to validate the action you took? I can't even begin to imagine.

In private, I heard some lovely folk express shock and outrage over how you were treated by the ultra-feminists, those women who can speak from positions of confidence only because generations of other women have fought to give them that opportunity. Not that they themselves have been victims of rape or discrimination or even close supporters of people struggling to stay out from under the control of those who feel they have a right to dominate and invalidate others.

As for your book, younger children respond to parables so well. Couching your story in a fictionalized way should be a good vehicle for them. Even if it's specialized. Even if it's available only in libraries and through sites that help children cope with the trauma. Even if it's only available online. So long as it's available.

So glad he's no longer around. So sorry you never got to see justice served in your lifetime.

Hugs and courage, sweetie!

Sarah Laurenson said...

Sometimes I love this manuscript and sometimes I don't. But it's been through it's own form of hell. It started out as a half poetry, half prose incest story. Then became an all prose incest story. Then it got smashed together with an all prose alcoholism story in which the MC had a different voice and was a different age.

I'm still smoothing over the large bumps. And it's still on the short side: ~18K words.

As for me, I think my good friend Nietzsche was right - I am stronger because of what I experienced. And I'm strong enough to know that murder is not the right answer - for me - in response. Sure there was a long time when thinking about gutting someone with a dull, rusty sword was satisfying, but the reality is I am not a violent person and do not wish to kill anything. I even take cockroaches out of the house and release them. :-)

stacy said...

Just when I think you can't knock me over with a feather, you do it again.

I'm sorry for what you went through. Glad he's gone.

Precie said...

Write. It sounds like this is an evolving work...or maybe multiple works...it doesn't sound like the kind of writing that can be scheduled. But it absolutely sounds like the kind of writing that must be done...for yourself...for other survivors...for children everywhere.

CatBookMom said...

Oh, my dear Sarah, you are such a strong woman. I hope that the process of writing your story, however it evolves, will be helpful to you; and I think it will be helpful to others should a publisher be wise enough.

Mother (Re)produces. said...

Another pile of hugs from me, Sarah. The audience for the book may be small, but perhaps someone will have the sense to see how important it might be to those few. How it's best to tell it in a way that they can process it (as Phoenix suggested, a parable) I don't know. This may require two versions. Good luck and lots of strength.

... said...

Cut yourself open & let yourself bleed all over the pages, Sarah. & let the blood of those who have hurt you bleed too. When you go back & read what you've read, the healing can come. In my own experience, honestly has always been the greatest healer of all for me. & as far as the questions you have in regard to the morale of these sensitive subjects & whether or not to expose them, look up Tender Morsels by Margo Lanagan. An internet bud who is a guy, but a feminist highly recommended it to me & it's YA & pretty brutal about incest & rape, but in such a way that might help you to see where you'd like to go with your own personal journey. Once I started reading that book I couldn't put it down.

I'm holding your hand Sarah ... I can empathize with your situation. *big, fat, internet hugs to you*